OddBot live forward test

I’m guessing it’s a typical case of the holiday season. Hopefully the vendor got back to you in the meantime. I strongly doubt morpheus fx above you is the developer.

Nope, as far as I know there’s only one version, no upsells. It’s just the name of the version at the time.

News avoidance is disabled. All the parameters are using their default settings except AutoMM which is set to 5.

Verify what exactly? It seems all good to me.

Unfortunately, that’s not possible because myfxbook does not have PrivateFX in their broker list and they’re not willing to add it because it’s not a brokerage that’s open for the public.

It’s normal to have small differences from a broker to another. I’m using the default settings, the only thing I changed was the AutoMM.

There is no option to set the GMT offset automatically, you must set it manually.

ECN would be the better option.

Sorry but I actually laughed out loud when reading that. And I’m doing that for all other EAs on my website, right? And taking care that the automatic myfxbook update that occurs at every 30 minutes does not “catch” the trades before they are modified? Also, in the past ~10 days there were 4 trades that closed at over -20 pips – what’s your theory about these, did I forget to modify them?

Anyway, care to post your results on a statement publishing site? I’m really curious to see how different they are.

Finally, are you aware that most EAs will exhibit differences when running on different brokers?

If you have a Pro account (the one where you pay commissions for each trade), then it’s almost ECN, yes. Otherwise, I’m pretty sure it isn’t.

As for finding accounts with Oddbot, I don’t know if you’ll be able to find exactly a Thinkforex account, but try searching for Oddbot on myfxbook and other Forex reporting sites.

Did you buy it via my affiliate link?

As for the different results, that always happens from a broker to another. Did you compare your account with other accounts publicly available on myfxbook? How did it compare to those? Do you have a MT4 Pro account or a regular MT4 account with ThinkForex? Care to post the results of your trading so that we can also see the difference?

Like I said in a post above, FXOpen for instance should have better execution than PrivateFX and a similar feed so it’s not like PrivateFX is the god of brokers, it’s actually more like an ECN with poor execution. You should be able to get results similar to mine (similar, not identical) on pretty much any ECN brokerage assuming they are really ECN.

If you are not paying commission, then it’s definitely not an ECN account, no matter what the broker support personnel tells you.

When I asked if you compared your results against other statements posted on myfxbook, I didn’t mean necessarily Thinkforex. You mentioned you are getting different results – does the difference become apparent when comparing to the trades on my account or is it the same when comparing with any other account? More so, you said your results are worse but you provided no details at all – are you getting slippage with your entries or exits? Are you getting completely different trades? What is the actual difference between your results and other results?

As for buying through my affiliate link, the reason I was asking is that the vendor’s affiliate interface reports no copies of Oddbot have been sold through me as an affiliate. Did anyone else purchase Oddbot after visiting the Morpheus site via my affiliate link?

Thanks for confirming and for your intention. There’s nothing you can do to check it from your end and it’s now clear that the affiliate system the vendor is using is completely broken (I’ve made a test).

I suggest keeping your Pepperstone account and moving only a part of the capital. From what I heard, Pepperstone is a rather decent brokerage (I’m not affiliated with them in any way). It’s somewhat normal to get different trades on different brokerages and I suspect it’ll even out in the end – you probably also have trades that I don’t have.

I’ve just checked other Oddbot accounts on myfxbook and on some other brokers (RoboForex, FXCC) the trade was closed in profit. I’ve also seen the 35 pip loss on other brokers, though: HotForex, even Pepperstone where DaveW didn’t experience it. I guess it simply depends on your broker’s price feed.