Expert Advisor Top – Compare Live Forward Performance

This page is meant to help everyone find and follow the live results of the best Forex robot that suits their trading style. The performances are analyzed and indexed in a way that permits the best trading system to make it to the top of the chart in a reasonable length of time – please see the details below the table for more information. All expert advisors on this page are running on live accounts.

[myfxbook_table]

Brief description of the column headings

    • Weeks in test – self explanatory.
    • Total gain – the total amount gained calculated in relation to the sum of the deposits (in most cases, it’ll be just the initial deposit).
    • Closed pips – the total number of pips realized by all the trades that were closed. Please note that this does not include the number of floating pips that might be the result of any open trades.
    • Monthly return – the monthly return figure calculated by Myfxbook.
    • Risk reward ratio – calculated by dividing the average losing trade by the average winning trade.
    • Winning trades – the percent of trades with a positive outcome.
    • Max closed drawdown – the maximum “realized” drawdown, meaning the largest drawdown ever encountered during the account lifetime. Please note that this does not take equity into account, so “unrealized” drawdowns from floating profits are not taken into account here. Basically, it’s the drawdown calculated by Myfxbook as the largest difference between a balance peak and the lowest following bottom.
    • Max drawdown (incl. floating) – unlike the closed drawdown above, this also includes floating (unrealized) drawdowns so in some cases it will be larger than its counterpart, especially for grid, martingale and hold-and-pray EAs.
    • Max floating drawdown pips – the maximum recorded value of floating negative profit, in pips.
    • Average trades per day – the number of average trades per day. Naturally, the calculation only includes trading days, the weekends are excluded.
    • Profit factor – the sum of all positive trades divided by the sum of all negative trades. A profit factor below 1 means the system is not currently profitable which should also be easily visible from the other stats.
    • Birt’s index – a performance index of my own based on a Sortino Ratio calculated on a weekly period, but also factoring the system lifetime and the floating drawdown. More details about its calculation are available. Please note that it’s a work in progress and it’s likely to change as time passes and its potential flaws are observed.
    • Balance chart – this one is pretty obvious.

Update frequency

The system details are updated about once every 30 minutes. The balance chart images and the Birt’s index figures are updated 4 times per day.

General info

This page is designed to continuously grow and list a wide array of expert advisors together with signal services. There are no limitations to the systems that will make it here. Even if an EA is on my No Review List it might still show up here. I recommend doing your due diligence before purchasing any systems that have not been fully reviewed.

As a general rule, I will stop systems that reach a drawdown in excess of 50% but I might make exceptions and stop them earlier or later depending on other factors.

To have an even ground, I am attempting to target a 5% monthly return and a maximum of 20% as drawdown for each system, but that’s mostly guesswork and it will surely vary wildly.

  • #88 written by matt October 19, 2014 (2 years ago)

    I wondered if you were planning on checking out and reviewing Rev Trader Pro, the official myfxbook link is here: http://www.myfxbook.com/members/revtraderpro/rev-trader-pro-real/1043229 Obviously it’s been traded from the start with very high risk settings but even if traded at say fixed 1 lot, the results would still have been very impressive. interesting to hear your opinion on this one

  • #89 written by pramod November 10, 2014 (2 years ago)

    hello
    I need to buy fapturbo.
    any one using now??these days

  • #90 written by gary June 25, 2015 (1 year ago)

    I have a copy I’m not using

  • #91 written by Mike July 19, 2015 (1 year ago)

    Hey Brit, your ‘league table’ of forex bots is awesome. A few questions from a newbie please?
    1) Do the figures (balance, total gains, monthly gains etc) take into account any ongoing costs of the software, or any costs involved of the trades themselves (i.e. are these gains net or gross)?
    2) Looking at the ‘balance’ charts and the overall gains figures, it is clear that some bots did very well some time ago, but have treaded water (or declined in value) since. I wonder if it is worth putting in some standardized medium term ‘gain’ (i.e. other than monthly/total). Perhaps a column showing how bots have performed over the last 12months?
    3) Do bots tend to have their code/algorithm updated? If not, this would suggest that their effectiveness would fade over time (making point 2 more relevant). What is a good ‘working lifetime’ of a bot?
    Thanks for any replies.
    Mike

  • #92 written by wan December 6, 2015 (12 months ago)

    What the best ea you thing??

  • #93 written by Steve December 16, 2015 (11 months ago)

    Keltner Pro, just for instance, shows 37549 closed pips on this page. On the MyFxbook page, it shows 4106 pips. I believe it’s the same time period. I don’t understand the discrepancy. What am I missing?
    Thanks

    • #94 written by birt December 17, 2015 (11 months ago)

      Most of the forward tests were stopped around 6 months ago and I started migrating some of the forward tests to demo accounts and this page to a new formula and format but never got to actually finishing it. That figure is definitely incorrect, possibly due to some change in the myfxbook API. I expect many of the others have the pips figure wrong.

  • #95 written by Steve December 17, 2015 (11 months ago)

    Thanks for your reply. Just to clarify, are you saying that the closed pips on the MyFxbook page are the accurate ones, and this page are likely not accurate?

    • #96 written by birt December 17, 2015 (11 months ago)

      I’m saying the pips here are most definitely not accurate while the ones on the myfxbook page are probably accurate.

      This page hasn’t been updated in ~6 months (I stopped the forward tests in June). Since the update used to be automated, I can’t manually modify the values displayed here so the value is stuck there until I’ll find the time to update everything :/

  • #97 written by david February 16, 2016 (9 months ago)

    Any plan to review “max scalper ea” pls?

  • You may use these HTML tags: <a> <abbr> <acronym> <b> <blockquote> <cite> <code> <del> <em> <i> <q> <s> <strike> <strong>

     

  • Comment Feed for this Post
Go to Top